I have a pair of Gearne boots and they've treated me well, but I also have wide feet, and I was after a pair of wide, waterproof boots..
After a bunch of research, I went with a pair of TCX http://www.tcxboots.com/usa/
X5 boots.. They're known to be wider than standard boots, and I have to agree..
I've worn them in down pours and not only are my feet dry, but comfortable..
They're actual GoreTex boots, rather than some internal waterproof and sweat causing water proof booty..
Check out the touring line, which has a nice dual sport boot if that's what you want, called the Infinity...
I bought mine because of other guys that I ride with had worn TCX for years of comfort and dryness while riding in rain.. I have to agree..