I agree with Damocles. It seems that if 2 people of exactly the same size buy the same windshield, one will love it and one will hate it. The worst part is, there's no way to know if it will work for you until you buy it, install it and try it out. I would recommend checking out any vendor's return policy to see if there's any chance you could return it if you don't like it.
At 6'4" I had the big Madstad and over time grew to dislike it. I removed it and it's never been back on since.
Also, a windshield is not a fail-safe facial protective device. A couple of years ago, while sporting said huge Madstad, I had a bird come up off the shoulder of the road, make it past the side of the windshield and hit me in the eye because I had my visor flipped up. If you've ever had somebody punch you right in the eye socket with their bare fist, that's what it felt like.
To each their own, but since that occurrence, I've never ridden with my visor up at highway speeds.
Anyway, good luck with your search. Hope you find something that works for you.