Kawasaki KLR Forum banner

1 - 20 of 32 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
327 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
So I just got my first pair of riding pants in the mail today in time for my trip this weekend and they fit perfectly! They are Icon ARC Overpants and are well rated when I researched. But problem is the stupid knee armor is basically ankle armor and with it all the way adjusted up, just barley velcroed on, I still cant get the pads high enough to cover my knees while sitting on my bike. :46: No way I can get another pair in time and if I wear them I doubt they will take them back ( I got them from www.motorcycle-superstore.com). I guess my question is more how much help is the armor if I screw up and go down or if someone hits me? My knees have had a few surgeries from football injuries and I care most about saving whats left of them so I am a bit freaked.

Do you guys think Im just being to n00b and its no big deal or should I swap for the cage and forget the awesome ride I planed out till I get better pants?
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,263 Posts
Well, before the panic attack sets in, let's look at the instructions. I know, instructions are for dweebs. The membership screening here is lax, and I got through.

http://www.newenough.com/browse/view_product_images/2162

Several sources indicate that the CE approved armor in the knees is adjustable, utilizing velcro.

Now for the "unsolicited advice". Built in armor is kind of convenient, and better than bare skin. But. The problem I find with most built in armor protection is that it is generically placed in generically sized off the rack gear. The seating on a sport bike is different than a KLR 650 is different than on a cruiser. They need to design these pants to "cover all bases". In the process, there are some trade offs. Sad part is, one of the trade off's is in the protection. Standing on the sidewalk, my knee armor droops a little below the knee. Seated on the bike, the knee armor rides up on my knee. What position will my knee be in when I'm tumbling down the road at 60 MPH? I dunno either. Nor do I know where my knee protection will be riding. Things happen pretty fast during most get-offs. My Aerostich armor stays in place. My other gear's armor is about as much lucky charm as it is functional. Solution? If you have a weak spot that you need protected, buy armor protection specific to the area. Throw away the crap in the suit. Do yourself and your knees a favor and get some "strap on" knee armor such as KNOX "cross knee" guards. You can ditch whatever armor comes in your pants and wear them. That way, you'll have PREMIUM knee protection no matter what position your knees/legs are in (walking, standing, crouched...it's still where it should be). Doesn't matter how your legs are bent, how many times they hit the ground, and will be familiar to you as they are ALWAYS in the same (proper) spot ALL the time. A side benifit of this is that the same pair of knee armor can be used under ANY pants you have, thus always feeling the same and comfortable.

What am I saying? I'm saying that your built in knee protection is not something I would count on in a crash. They move. Unpredictably. There are too many if's and maybe's to rely on the built in pants protection.

Solution.

http://www.newenough.com/browse/view_product_images/184

http://www.webbikeworld.com/r4/alpinestars-reflex-knee-guards/

Popular

http://www.rockymountainatvmc.com/productDetail.do?navType=type&priceRange=$9+-+$109&navTitle=Apparel-MXGear&webTypeId=86&webCatId=1&brandId=allBrands&prodFamilyId=13867

Your local motorcycle shops will have these or a version of them. Yes, they may be five or six dollars higher than on the internet. But you get to try them on and make sure they fit. And go on your trip.

And keep asking questions about safety equipment. And fit. If I jump from a plane, I do not want the bargain brand parachute, nor do I want a sweat shop packing it. What we are doing is not that far removed.

I don't have economy knees. They get better than economy protection.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
4,751 Posts
And, if all else fails and none of your repair attempts work and you decide that you must have knee protection, visit Home Depot and grab a pair of knee protectors.. They have everything from armored to just foam. While you'll find them a bit more heavy duty than what the pants came with, that's not a bad thing, right?? :)

Vatrader hit it on the head.. They're designed for everyone and we're not all the same size.. If we were, I wouldn't have had to sell my original Aerostich Roadcrafter due to closet shrinkage..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,928 Posts
My .02...

If I had prior knee injuries/surgeries I would be wearing knee braces not guards especially if you're going off-road. The difference is that the braces will limit hyper extensions and lateral twisting. Yea braces are expensive but if you've already done the doctor route, well you know.

I have Astericks that I wear on my dirt bikes. If I were buying new I would get the EVS RS8 braces

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
327 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
I did adjust them all the way till only a flimsy bit of velcro was holding them up and it wasn't enough. Guess that part of what I said wasn't worded right sorry. Looking at the sizing chart on the site you gave me I can see the problem right away, the inseam seems to be at lest 2" longer then what I am. Everything fits perfectly leg length and all, just the velcro placement is so low so I am totally confused. Either way I guess the stuff is really flimsy even if it was right.

I have seen those knee guards for MX riders in the past and those are an awesome idea! And if I dont find any that fit right away then Home Depot it will be for this trip. I am picking up my new windshield today so will be at the shop and check them out.

I wasn't trying to be cheap I just went by the few personable reviews of my friends who ride sport bikes. They have been down with Icon gear and say it kept them out of the ER a few times. Everything else is just stars and hear-say. Shops don't carry my size so all I can go by is ppl who have been there, been down, and swear by it. That said, vatrader, are you implying these are cheap pants? I have no clue what I am doing and just want to ride. So if so then are they worth my keeping even with my own knee guards? Everyone seems to love Aerostich but I have been reading resent reviews saying they are having major delivery issues the last couple months. Anything else I should be looking at maybe something Dual sport specific? I will be happy to return and spend more on better gear I just don't know what is really better and what is just, "paying for the name."
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
327 Posts
Discussion Starter #6 (Edited)
Spec,

What is the difference between the Astericks and the EVS RS8 braces?

Edit: WOW only about twice as much! So which is better and why? What does the extra bucks get you between the two?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,928 Posts
Spec,

What is the difference between the Astericks and the EVS RS8 braces?

About 300 bucks!

The Asterisks are a bit bulky and would be hard to fit under street oriented pants. I haven't seen the EVS braces in person but they look slimer maybe not but they are a newer design.

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
327 Posts
Discussion Starter #8
HAHA So much to think about! Looks like bungee cords and duffle bags will have to get the job done for now, Safety first!

Are the Icons worth even keeping?
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,263 Posts
I did adjust them all the way till only a flimsy bit of velcro was holding them up and it wasn't enough. Guess that part of what I said wasn't worded right sorry. Looking at the sizing chart on the site you gave me I can see the problem right away, the inseam seems to be at lest 2" longer then what I am. Everything fits perfectly leg length and all, just the velcro placement is so low so I am totally confused. Either way I guess the stuff is really flimsy even if it was right.

I have seen those knee guards for MX riders in the past and those are an awesome idea! And if I dont find any that fit right away then Home Depot it will be for this trip. I am picking up my new windshield today so will be at the shop and check them out.

I wasn't trying to be cheap I just went by the few personable reviews of my friends who ride sport bikes. They have been down with Icon gear and say it kept them out of the ER a few times. Everything else is just stars and hear-say. Shops don't carry my size so all I can go by is ppl who have been there, been down, and swear by it. That said, vatrader, are you implying these are cheap pants? I have no clue what I am doing and just want to ride. So if so then are they worth my keeping even with my own knee guards? Everyone seems to love Aerostich but I have been reading resent reviews saying they are having major delivery issues the last couple months. Anything else I should be looking at maybe something Dual sport specific? I will be happy to return and spend more on better gear I just don't know what is really better and what is just, "paying for the name."
I have no idea if they are cheap or not. By your description, they seem to be ineffective, which I consider to be more of an issue than price. If they don't offer protection, I will go out on a limb and state that they have little value.

I was not being critical of your choice of gear. I wanted you to be aware that what you encountered was not uncommon. And that there are options if better protection is a concern. It matters little to me who makes it or what it costs. It must, however, do it's job.

I am a little phobic about nylon that melts into your hide when it slides down asphalt. The material your outerwear is made of is as important as the impact protection of the padding. Most of all, I want you and everybody else to discuss anything and everything related to rider safety. Until we all puke. With the technology we have, it is becoming safer to ride. We just need to help each other become aware of what is available by coming forth with our experience. I will believe another rider long before I buy into the latest marketing ploy. Money has tightened up. What is available needs to be spent wisely and I need to get as much effective life out of each item as I can. Without loosing sight of the effective part.
 

·
Threadjacker
Joined
·
6,768 Posts
Man, vatrader's response was right on. I have a pair of riding pants and I agree...I often wonder if the knee pads would still be on my knees doing a tumble. Here is what I do, and I am not recommending it, just being honest. I wear full armored gear all the time with the exception of pants. I ALWAYS wear 'draggin jeans' kevlar long underwear. Basically, this does nothing for impact protection, but would theoretically save some skin as there is kevlar woven into the butt/hip and knees. When I am riding someplace I don't feel comfortable I have a set of Icon knee pads I wear over my pants. I agree...knee pads that strap on will serve you better. So, anyway, that's what I do. Do you need knee protection? On the safety forum I used to frequent a guy posted some post biff pics and apparently his knee hit one of those raised lane dividers. It took a HELL of a big chunk out of his knee pads. I would hate to have seen the same thing happen to a knee. But, I'm a little hypocritical on this issue. I should be better about it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
327 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
You guys are awesome! :35a: Thank you all very much for helping me. Going to have to just get through this week with what I got and figure out the best set up when I get home.

Adding to my stupidity I just had to stumble into a face plant section right before I go out for my first week long ride. :85a: HAHAHAHA

Going to be a fun week and I hope you all enjoy and ride safe! :character00201:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
127 Posts
Lockjaw,
Why do you wear the icon knee pads on the outside? do they not fit under your pants? And how would you rate them for comfort and safety?
Thanks.
 

·
Threadjacker
Joined
·
6,768 Posts
They fit pretty well. I wear them over my pants so I can take them on and off easier. I think they are a good product. I played soccer my whole life and my calf muscles are big. Any bigger and the guards wouldn't fit. That's my only complaint. Never gone down with them on, but they seem rugged. If I were going to do it again, I would try on a few others, but the Icon are good and if you have normal sized calfs, they'd be even better. :)

They're about as comfortable as knee pads can be, I think.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
127 Posts
I'm in the process of buying some knee pads, as well as a back protector.
The Icon's are my top choice for the knees right now.
You say you'd try other brands - which ones? are there specific ones you're thinking of?
 

·
Threadjacker
Joined
·
6,768 Posts
No nothing specific. I'd just go try some on. But I think you'd like the Icons...I got them cause they were on sale at NewEnough, but they're a good product.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
127 Posts
Thanks

Perfect. I'll get a pair of those then. :)
Thanks for the feedback.
 

·
Threadjacker
Joined
·
6,768 Posts
Sure thing.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
127 Posts
Feedback on the Icon Knee Guards coming...

They're in the mail. I'll try to put a couple of hundred miles this weekend and let you know how they feel. Do you use them when you go to work also? if you do, do you take them off when you get to work, or keep them on all day? My ride to work is only 10 miles, but they say you always get into an accident closest from home.
 

·
Threadjacker
Joined
·
6,768 Posts
This is the conversation I hate because I wish I could say I wear them every time I touch a bike, but I just don't. If I am going offroad or doing an aggressive ride I will. Otherwise its kevlar long johns and hope. It's stupid. I wouldn't let me daughter or anyone I love ride without knee protection. It's like when I used to smoke. Different rules for me. I am stubborn as a mule but not as smart much of the time.

My hypocritical advice? Wear them ALL the time. And yeah, you're gonna want to take them off when you're not on the bike. They aren't that comfortable for walking.

I'm glad this all came up actually. I need to think on this...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
127 Posts
Atgatt?

I think the exact same way you do Lockjaw.

I try to wear all of the equipment I have all of the time. I just started riding 2yrs ago (3rd season this year) and so I don't have all of the equipment other people have yet - I've been buying it slowly as time and money allows.

But now, I've just purchased a back protector, and the knee guards. And this is where I'm questioning whether I'll wear it all of the time. My brain is telling me to wear it all - ALL of the time. :46:

The back protector is another good example. If it's hot, as it's been in the last few days, and i take my jacket off as I go into a store to buy some more water, do I take the back protector off? Do I keep it on and does it look weird?
I guess I'm old enough that I don't care if it looks weird.

But it's like you say, I'm always pushing for my riding friends to improve their safety, so i have to make the effort also. We'll see when my stuff comes in the mail tomorrow. :)
 
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
Top